

E.M. Forester wrote of connections, the importance of them in our lives in an attempt to attain more meaningful and whole existence.
Unfortunately, this concept was lost on the film, Babel. One would expect out of confusion, truth would somehow manage to creep in and as man vs. man, man vs. the elements, man vs. himself, there would be a point of redemption, at least a small glimmer of redemption. Not so in Babel.
As far as direction and cinemotography and in some cases characterization (the Japanese deaf mute, the Mexican Nanny), Babel was brillant. The Mexican Boda scene was entirely accurate, we have attended several in the hills, so bravo. But as a multidimensional film, with a solid message, we are left lacking.
Further, for a film whose basis is supposed to be 'truth', it simply was not. The depiction of the encounter with the US Border Patrol was fallacious. The film made the Agents out to be thuglike. We must assume this was present day, since the word 'terrorism' was bandied around, however, the present day Tecate crossing is nothing like the movie suggests it is. In real life, if this had really happened, immediately after the suspicion of drunk driving, or even after the Nanny produced the passports of the young children, and yet no papers for herself, the occupants would have been told to get out of the vehicle. Especially in light of the numerous child abductions and kidnappings these days. They would have been escorted to Secondary, and the vehicle would have been driven to Secondary by Agents and then searched. No way would an Agent have the driver reenter the car and have him follow the agent to Secondary.
Further, the topography for the Tecate area is wrong. Tecate is hilly with thick brush. The desert is at least another half hours drive east. The enounter with the BP Agent in the desert with the Nanny is also wrong. The first thing our agents do is offer medical assistance and water, not cuff the poor bastards. They take care of the physical needs first and foremost.
I never cared too much for the Americans in the film, but there was really a disconnect when I found out they had employed this poor woman for nearly 8 years, could afford to live in San Diego, a trip to Morocco and yet, never helped her achieve legal status. Not to mention not allowing her to attend her son's Boda. Weddings down here are a big fucking deal, this never would have happened. Preparations go on for months and months in advance, so unbelievable. Mike suggested that perhaps the rendering of the Americans as being self indulgent was intentional, but even if that were true, it is typecasting and sophomoric. We all know there are assholes in America, but to colour all of us this way is just another form of stereotype.
Better bet for an outstanding film which unfairly received little review: Lady In The Water, check it out.
See you guys later.
Labels: BABEL IS CONFUSION